Scalia: What next for the Supreme Court?

“The word ‘brilliant’ is overused,”
said Mona Charen in National
Review. But in the case of Justice
Antonin Scalia, who died a
fortnight ago, “it may be too
weak”. In his 29 years on the US
Supreme Court, Scalia used his
caustic wit and intelligence to
bring new vigour to what had
previously been the dullest of
America’s three branches of
government. His arguments didn’t
always carry the day; indeed, he
wrote more of his famously
blistering dissents than he did
of majority opinions. But by
championing the conservative
legal philosophy known as
“originalism” – which holds that
courts should be guided by the meaning of the Constitution as it
was originally written – he was hugely influential. Scalia, said
Stephen Calabresi in USA Today, was quite simply “the most
important justice in American history”.
“Good riddance,” said Paul Rosenberg on Salon.com. For all
Scalia’s charm and vaunted devotion to the “rule of law”, his
opinions were appallingly reactionary. In the infamous Citizens
United decision of 2010, he decided that when the Founders
said “free speech”, they meant money – a ruling that struck
down campaign funding limits and accelerated the corruption of
US politics. And who can forget his nakedly partisan, circular
logic in concurring with the Bush v. Gore ruling that handed
the 2000 presidential election to the Republicans? If Florida
were allowed to recount the votes of its citizens, Scalia
reasoned, it might reveal that Al Gore had won the election,
thus “casting a cloud” over the legitimacy of the rightful
president, George W. Bush.
In 2012, said Charles Krauthammer in The Washington Post,
Scalia remarked that he wouldn’t retire until a Republican was
back in the White House. “I would not like to be replaced,” he
explained, “by someone who
immediately sets about undoing
everything that I’ve tried to do
for 25 years”. But that is now
a real danger. If President Obama
replaces Scalia with a left-wing
justice, the closely balanced
Supreme Court will be split 5-4
in favour of liberals, potentially
ushering in a new era of
left-wing judicial activism.
That’s why the Republicans are
quite rightly insisting that they
will block any new appointment
until after the presidential
election in November.
Get ready for what could be “the
meanest nomination battle in
modern American history”, said Jonah Goldberg in the Los
Angeles Times. It’s going to “get very ugly”. Democrats have
accused the GOP of violating a “sacred norm” by vowing to
block Obama’s Supreme Court appointee, yet they’ve done the
same in the past. But the Republicans are taking a gamble, said
Mark Joseph on Slate.com. If they win the White House, they’ll
get to choose Scalia’s successor. But what if a Democrat wins?
They could appoint a very liberal nominee, and then “no
conservative precedent would be safe”. Not the right to bear
arms enshrined in District of Colombia v. Heller, not Citizens
United, not the death penalty. Why don’t Republicans at least
consider a “compromise candidate”?
The row over Scalia’s replacement promises to add “an extra
layer of insanity” to a presidential campaign “already defined
by radicals and demagogues”, said Ross Douthat in The New
York Times. The irony is that this clash between law and
politics is exactly the kind of thing Scalia’s legal philosophy
tried to keep in check, by “promoting a more limited vision
of the Supreme Court’s role” in America. “But for his
influence, in this effort he clearly failed – and what’s about
to come will prove it.”


Best Roach Killer 2020 Best Wood Glue Best Power Inverter
Best Electric Knife Sharpener Best Outdoor Solar Lights Best Lawn Fertilizer
Best Wood Stove Best Insect Repellent Best Deer Repellent
Best Drain Cleaner Best Lawn Edger Best Gaming Monitor
Best Memory Foam Mattress Best Gaming Keyboarda Best Air Mattress
Best Air Fryer Best Gaming Mouse Best Coffee Grinder
Best Gaming Headset Best Gaming Chair Best Tool Belt
Best Soldering Iron Best Pruning Saw Best Backpacking Tent
Best Torque Wrench Best Car Battery Charger Best Adjustable Wrench
Best Digital Caliper Best Concrete Cleaner Best Cordless Screwdriver
facts about Italy facts about Germany facts about Poland
facts about France facts about Hollland facts about Mexico
facts about Peru facts about Spain facts about Pakistan
facts about Costa Rica facts about Ireland facts about Egypt
facts about Jordan facts about Armenia facts about Israel
facts about Philippines facts about Panama facts about Russia
facts about Madagascar facts about Haiti facts about Hong Kong
facts about Bahamas facts about Kenya facts about Benin
facts about Guyana facts about Tunisia facts about Malawi
facts about Norway facts about Scotland facts about Sweden
facts about North Korea facts about Bolivia facts about Argentina
facts about England facts about Portugal facts about Finland
facts about Malaysia facts about Greece facts about Canada
facts about Croatia facts about Cambodia facts about Bangladesh
facts about South Africa facts about Hungary facts about New Zealand
facts about China facts about Thailand facts about Vietnam
facts about Saudi arabia facts about Iceland facts about Venezuela
facts about Ireland facts about India facts about Chile
facts about Indonesia facts about Singapore facts about Jamaica
facts about Japan facts about Brazil facts about South Korea
facts about canada facts about Italy facts about Columbia
facts about Mexico facts about USA weird facts North Korea
facts about Slovenia facts about Australia facts about Country
simple facts Venezuela simple facts South Korea simple facts New Zealand
simple facts Jamaica simple facts Greece simple facts Canada
simple facts China simple facts England simple facts Argentina
simple facts Bolivia simple facts South Africa simple facts India
simple facts Thailand simple facts Australia simple facts Bangladesh
simple facts Japan simple facts USA simple facts Czech
simple facts St.Vincent simple facts Ivory Coast simple facts Switzeland
structured settlement company structured settlements annuities structured settlement buyer
small business administration structured settlement purchasers houston tx auto insurance
selling structured settlement selling annuity structered settlement
caraccidentlawyer auto accident attorney Torrance attorney orange county
attorneys orange county personal injury accident lawyer car accident lawyers los angeles
cheap travel insurance los angeles motorcycle accident state of california car insurance
selling a structured settlement hughes net business structured settlement need cash
fast cash for house maritime lawyer houston personal injury attorney ocala fl
home equity loan reverse mortgage us bank home mortgage
personal loans for bad credit peer to peer lending home equity loan rates
refinance mortgage personal loan rates first time home buyer programs
cash out refinance home mortgage rates mortgage lenders
homeowners insurance home insurance state farm car insurance
comprehensive insurance commercial insurance cheap auto insurance
cheap health insurance indemnity car insurance companies
progressive quote usaa car insurance insurance near me
term life insurance auto insurance near me state farm car insurance
comprehensive insurance progressive home insurance house insurance
progressive renters insurance state farm insurance quote metlife auto insurance
best insurance companies progressive auto insurance quote cheap car insurance quotes
allstate car insurance rental car insurance car insurance online
liberty mutual car insurance cheap car insurance near me best auto insurance
home insurance companies usaa home insurance list of car insurance companies
full coverage insurance allstate insurance near me cheap insurance quotes
national insurance progressive home insurance house insurance
health insurance quotes ameritas dental state farm renters insurance
medicare supplement plans progressive renters insurance aetna providers
title insurance sr22 insurance medicare advantage plans
aetna health insurance ambetter insurance umr insurance
massmutual 401k private health insurance assurant renters insurance
assurant insurance dental insurance plans state farm insurance quote
health insurance plans workers compensation insurance geha dental
metlife auto insurance boat insurance aarp insurance
costco insurance flood insurance best insurance companies
cheap car insurance quotes best travel insurance insurance agents near me
car insurance car insurance quotes auto insurance
auto insurance quotes long term care insurance auto insurance companies
home insurance quotes cheap car insurance quotes affordable car insurance
professional liability insurance cheap car insurance near me small business insurance
vehicle insurance best auto insurance full coverage insurance
motorcycle insurance quote homeowners insurance quote errors and omissions insurance
general liability insurance best renters insurance cheap home insurance
cheap insurance near me cheap full coverage insurance cheap life insurance
horrible serial killer beautiful phenomena deadly UFO attacks
most mysterious sounds creepiest website most toxic ghost towns
coronavirus explained deepest hole in the world weirdest discoveries
what is darkest material facts about mars facts about sun
most dangerous plant most science facts most venomous snakes
most dangerous animals dangerous africa animals most venomous spider
dangerous gangs all time weird and gross candy weird history story
most bizarre hobbies most bizarre trends most banned foods
most dangerous jobs make money online way facts about Jamaica
most dangerous countries most visited cities most evil people
best airports in the world best capitals in the world best places in the world

will refinancing hurt my credit va loan multi family va loan after chapter 7 va home loan specialist us bank home mortgage top insurance companies tax debt relief program tax credit for college students structured settlement loan small business loans personal loan rates permanent life insurance payday loans online no credit check loans national guard va home loan mortgage life insurance maximum fha loan amount low cost health insurance Irs Tax Debt Relief Program how to get preapproved for a va home loan how long does a credit card balance transfer take homeowners insurance companies home loan interest rate home equity line of credit health insurance free car insurance quotes fixed annuity fha loan foreclosure waiting period does opening a checking account affect credit define insurance brokers current mortgage rates cost to refinance home loan Compare Vehicle Insurance cheap travel insurance bad credit car loans average home insurance cost

No comments:

Post a Comment